I have been drinking the beer for the last three weeks and have been pretty happy with it (although some sips still seem to have the stronger alcohol taste - not sure how that's possible). There have been quite a few process changes since I brewed this batch (and no repeat of these issues) so I'm not sure what it really tells me except that a bad beer can mature given time and turn into something drinkable.
Tasting Notes:
- Aroma:
- It has a nice, but subdued, roasted malt smell to it. I get a little bit of chocolate as well. There is also a nice bit of sweetness in the aroma.
- Appearance:
- It has a really rich, beautiful, black color (the picture does it pretty good justice). The head is beige. It fades down do a thin layer after an average pour.
- Flavor:
- With some age the alcohol has faded into the background for the most part. Up front I get a little bit of a sweet flavor with some malty complexity. The finish is almost all roasted grain with maybe a tiny bit of chocolate mixed in. It's a relatively restrained roastyness compared with an Irish Stout but still pretty dry on the finish. I don't really get any hops or yeast ester character from it at this point. The flavor definitely gets a lot fuller and richer as the beer warms up - It's about 60 F at the moment which seems to be about the perfect temperature.
- Mouth-Feel:
- It has a medium body. Even with light carbonation it doesn't feel thin (now that the alcohol flavor has cleared up). It think the body is about right for an oatmeal stout - this is about what I had thought it would be like anyway. The finish is quite dry but not at all unpleasant.
- Overall:
- Now that it's matured I think it's a pretty nice stout. It's dry and roasty the way I would expect a stout to be but not aggressively so. I wish there was a bit more going on in the finish than the dry roastyness. As it is, it's not unpleasant anymore but it's a bit one dimensional.
So, I am very happy that the beer improved but not completely happy with the end results. It think a bit more chocolate and some additional residual sweetness to the beer would have been interesting. This recipe was a nice starting stout but I'm not sure I'll use it as any sort of basis for recipes going forward - too much going on with that grain bill.